March – Where’d you go, Bernadette?

March is a crazy busy month for me, so I was glad to have two fairly short, very different books to read this month. I did find myself finishing ‘Into the wild’ an hour before the book club meeting, but hey there’s nothing like a deadline to make you stop washing up and sit down and read for an hour.

Where’d you go, Bernadette – Maria Semple

13526165

At first, this book is a little hard to read, written in an unusual style, the story is told through letters, emails, phone calls and the first person account of Bee, and this makes it quite disjointed. However, when you get used to the style, and you develop empathy for the characters, it is unputdownable. This is not a massive problem unless you have something urgent to do because you should be able to read the book in a day, so it is not a major commitment.

Bernadette is fabulous, I mean, yeh sure she is cantankerous, and she is petty, but she is surrounded by the worst kind of people (fake, Stepford type Mums), so from quite early on in the book I was on her side. The arty side of me hated that she had once been so creative, and now was stuck in a house that could not be altered, in a life that was so mundane, with an expectation from the other mothers that she should ‘join in’ more with school activities. I have been there, there IS a very real expectation that you will volunteer for school trips, sewing days, and fundraising activities. Hell, I have baked the most amazing cupcakes for my kid’s school, only to see them sold for 20p each (Not enough to cover the cost of ingredients, let alone make it worth the 3 hours I put in). So I was with Bernadette from the start, when she simply said no, and didn’t even bother to explain herself.

Bee is a great kid, doing fabulously at school, and fully recovered from the heart condition that threatened her life for her first few years. She is totally and utterly there for her Mum, and that in itself is wonderful, I love her devotion to a woman who is a fantastic mother, but does not feel the need to prove it to the whole community. Audrey is a self-righteous bitch, and I have met her, several times in my life. If the book teaches us anything and teaches it well, it is that there are two sides to every story. Soo lin is a ridiculous stereotype (falling for the boss), but even that is written well enough for me to accept it. The joy of this book is that people are flawed, they are far from perfect, and yet you will find yourself cheering for them. The group scored this book a solid 3.5* and I gave it 4*, it was easy to read and lighthearted, but I am not keen on the ending.

Into the Wild – Jon Krakauer

91GZtPaNeFL._SL1500_

I am not a fan of ‘finding yourself via an epic adventure’ type books, and there was something kind of irritating about this ignorant of his surroundings, stubborn little brat, who had no interest in how his actions might affect his family, but I kept reading. I think that for me, the most important thing about this book was that it was written in a way that kept me reading. It was not chronological, and as such had the potential to be confusing, but for me, I think if it was chronological, I would have been bored, because I didn’t care much enough McCandless. The people that he met along the way, were the soul of the story, and some of these characters are great and well written, and the way the narrative jumped about, kept me interested.

Krakauer’s (narrator) own history as a young rebellious risk-taker seemed to colour his judgment of McCandless and gave him an understanding of what drove him on. Krakauer’s recollection of his own big adventure only made me think that he was probably not the best person to tell this story objectively. I was going to give the book 2.5* as it was neither great nor awful, but then it made me cry, yes, actual tears so I gave it 3*. The rating from the group was in and around the 3.5* mark, and I guess if you liked ‘wild’ you’d love this, but I wouldn’t recommend that you rush out to get it.

Happy reading!
Mel x

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s