October – The watcher in the shadows

It was one of those months when I had already made my mind up about the books before even reading them. I KNEW I was going ot love the Zafon book, and I KNEW that ‘The reader’ would be a chore to read, but pre conceptions can be wrong…

The Watcher in the Shadows – Carlos Ruiz Zafon

9780753829257

The watcher in the shadows is not quite Zafon at his best, but it is a reasonable little read. For an author with the skill to write ‘The shadow of the wind’ and ‘The angel’s game’ which are utterly outstanding, this is a little disappointing. It is important to remember though that, although this book was published in 2013, it was written in 1995, six years prior to TSOTW, when Zafon was still perfecting his craft, and was written for a teenage audience.

Honestly the book isn’t great, there are holes in the story, and we are expected to believe the unbeliveable ‘but Mel’, I hear you say ‘it is a fantasy novel, of course it is unbelievable’. The genre isn’t what made it unbelieveable though, it was the fact that even in a fantasy novel, this storyline didn’t gel, it didn’t work. The creepy clockwork toys and evil shadows just weren’t enough to make it worth reading. I gave the book 3.5* but that is very generous, and based on the target audience (13 year olds might love it) and my general love of Zafon as an author. The group gave it an average 2.5* which is more realistic if I’m honest.

Don’t bother, read ‘Shadow of the wind’ instead!

The Reader – Bernhard Schlink

51UHwHQ5lCL._SX323_BO1,204,203,200_

Three things I learned from reading ‘The Reader’ –

  1. I really love books with parts. Chapters are good, but when a book is divided into parts I actually love when one part ends and I really don’t know where the next part is going to take the story.
  2. I do not like book covers that are images from a film. I kinda knew this, but I actually couldn’t get this without a picture of Kate Winslet in the bath on the cover, this annoyed me intensely.
  3. Sometimes a book starts a bit meh, but it can still grab me. I also kinda knew this, and this is why I always try to get 1/2 way through a book before judging it, but this book reminded me.

I didn’t love this book when I started reading it, but I found it really easy to read, so I carried on. Part one of the book concentrates on the narrator’s youth, and a realationship that he had when he was a young teen with a much older woman. I found this part of the book uncomfortable (the relationship was a bit weird regardless of the age gap) and really didn’t want to read any more about this relationship, so was pleased when part 2 moved to another time in his life, and the subject matter (the concentration camps in the war) was fascinating, if incredibly sad. In the end I gave the book 4* and the group average was the same, it is definitely worth a read.

Happy Reading!

Mel x

 

Advertisements